My Long-Term Relationship with Fanfiction

Although we’re currently on an unofficial break, I would without hesitation classify my relationship with fanfiction as serious and long-term. We’ve known each other for years and grown together, through ship wars and show cancellations.

It’s a relationship that overlaps with an impressionable and formative period of my life, yes, but also one that shapes the way I engage with the world and media I encounter every day. It’s influenced my feelings about different kinds of relationships, familiarity with tropes, technical writing skills, perseverance to finish stories, confidence to share my work, awareness beyond my “vision” to the potential impact of my words on others … 

Yes, I know this all sounds a bit melodramatic, which probably doesn’t help support the case that fanfiction isn’t just for moony-eyed teenage girls who want their favorite fictional characters to make out. But it really is so much more than that, and I hope sharing my experiences will help convince you otherwise. (Or if you are/were a fanfic’er yourself, hopefully you can relate!)

Just so we’re clear: I’m not going to get into the argument of whether fanfiction should be considered “original” works, or the legal / moral nuances when playing in another writer’s sandbox, or any of the discourse surrounding fic and fandom culture in general. (I do have a lot of strong opinions on these topics, but I haven’t yet done the research or personal reflection to properly back them up. Maybe I’ll write a post about it when I do.)


1. Attraction

We met when I was in middle school.

One of my friends had sent me the link to a pirate AU for the anime Mai-HiME β€” in case you’re curious, it’s this one which unfortunately hasn’t been updated since 2012. I kept up with it and another fic from the same author (same fandom, same pairing; different setting), but I didn’t really fall down the rabbit hole then.

There’s not much to say about this first foray except that I didn’t give it much of a second thought. While it wasn’t as polished as most published works, it was an interesting, well-told story; I hadn’t watched the anime, so the characters were totally unfamiliar to me. In hindsight, I’m amazed that the central F/F romance and mild smut didn’t even phase me, considering this would’ve been one of my first experiences with either. 

Probably a few months later, I got really into Tokyo Mew Mew (first the manga, then the anime. I still tend to make a point of reading the book first). My favorite pairing didn’t end up together, in spite of one major plot moment when they easily could have, and I somehow found myself on, diving deep into the fandom.

I became very familiar with the site filters and the most popular authors. But I still wasn’t satisfied with the way the aforementioned pivotal scene was handled β€” i.e., there wasn’t enough canon divergent fic surrounding it.

So I started writing it myself. (No, I’m not sharing the link. I actually couldn’t if I wanted to; some of my early fics are still up, but that one’s been deleted.)


2. Uncertainty

I immediately made the rookie mistakes of posting each chapter as I finished it and of writing multiple fics at the same time. As anyone who reads and/or writes fic will know, that unfortunately often means

  • sporadic updates
  • long waits between updates
  • fics that end up unofficially on hiatus for literal years
  • and more!

But at the same time, what I did post received some really lovely encouragement (reviews, favorites, and follows), which bolstered my inspiration to keep going. I felt some guilt that I could’ve been using that time to study, practice piano, or work on my original writing … though not so much that I really stopped.


3. Struggle

When it comes to fandoms and ships, it turns out I’m incredibly monogamous. Although I adored Harry Potter for years, by middle school it was totally eclipsed by The Mortal Instruments, and in high school I was almost exclusively focused on The 100. People joke about having too many OTPs (One True Pairing, aka the top ship you would absolutely go down with), but I’ve usually only had one at a time.

(I did have background ships β€” one does not simply stop caring about Percabeth or Kanej β€” which persisted throughout, and there’s often some overlap while I wrap up some projects before moving on. But for the most part I prefer to immerse myself in the personalities and minutiae of one series at a time.)

So transitioning between fandoms is always a struggle. Even ignoring the WIPs that I promise to eventually finish [but even now have yet to complete], fandom is a very social experience. It sucks to leave your friends behind, and it sucks to go back to feeling like no one is reading your fics. 

To make matters worse, I was falling out of love with my own WIPs. Ironically, my best-received fic β€” The Mortal Instruments, all-human high school AU β€” was the one I least wanted to work on, because I’d written myself into a plot hole and because the pressure of expectations started getting to me. (Also, to be quite honest, every “please update!!!1!!1!!!!!!1!!” review ignited my spiteful streak.)

I never at any point officially gave up or decided to quit, but I’d certainly lost the flow.


4. Stability

Although it was a slow build and I never quite achieved the same popularity I reached in the TMI fic fandom, my last major fandom has been my longest running one: I wrote and posted Bellarke (Bellamy/Clarke, The 100) fic consistently for over three years.

There were canon-compliant scenes and high school / college AUs and ambiguous songfics; I filled requests and prompts, created moodboards and playlists to go with some of the bigger projects.

At my best, I had pages and pages of ideas, half-written stories, hundreds of canon quotes to draw from. I was engaged in the fandom, with a decently popular Tumblr dedicated to The 100 and solid relationships with other fans of the show, on both Tumblr and AO3. (Just as most blog engagement comes from fellow bloggers, most fic engagement seems to come from fellow fic writers.) Every song I heard seemed written specifically for some alternate-universe iteration of these characters; every movie I watched had potential to be adapted to their relationship.

The key was probably a combination of fandom engagement and my consistent free time. I knew when I could write, so I never fell out of the flow [until I did … after a few years] and I knew with whom I could banter ideas.


5. Commitment

For years, I had looked forward to college, where I expected to be living the Cath Avery life: staying up writing fic instead of studying, maybe finding a creative-writing professor / mentor if I was lucky. I even had a fairly popular fic in progress, so I already related to her on several levels.

Instead I went and got a social life and a romantic relationship with a real person. (And I started actually studying for exams … somewhat.) I stopped checking Tumblr and eventually I stopped checking AO3; my WIP docs were upstaged by essays and textbook PDFs. Friday nights were for Super Smash Bros Brawl tournaments instead of writing.

Don’t get me wrong, I love my friends and I’m glad that I don’t have academic regrets thus far. So I don’t think I would do it any differently, given the chance, especially since it happened naturally. I missed all the different aspects of fic β€” the actual writing, the community, the sheer love of a specific series, the feeling of inspiration β€” but to be honest it rarely crossed my mind. 

Lately I’ve been reading a lot of articles talking about how young people today have commitment issues, avoiding serious long-term monogamous relationships. These are usually viewed negatively, but I’ve never seen a problem with it as long as everyone involved is on the same page. 

So I recently started getting back into fic, experimenting with different formats and plot bunnies. It’s not a grand return; I haven’t timeboxed it into my weekly schedule or decided what to do with my remaining WIPs. I haven’t even published anything new. But I’m gradually figuring out how it fits into my life, as one of several things I love to do, and for now that’s enough. I want to make this work, so I probably will.

I swear not all my writing revolves around love and relationships, despite an emerging pattern to the contrary! But I think it’s an interesting and influential topic β€” and an extremely subjective one; none of the sources I consulted agreed on the stages of a relationship, though they do generally consider there to be five distinct stages.

Anyway, what books / shows / fandoms most influenced your views on romance and relationships? How familiar are you with fanfiction / fandom culture? (You don’t have to confess to self-insert OC fics, but more power to ya if you want to!)

19 thoughts on “My Long-Term Relationship with Fanfiction

  1. I have definitely read A LOT of fanfic. In fact, I think if I read actual books that counted towards my GR goal, then I’d probably be closer to hitting 100 books each year.
    I have also dabbled in writing fanfic, but I’ve never been brave enough to publish it. (I mean, it probably doesn’t help that my name on AO3 is not really all that anonymous…)
    However, I agree that there is a place for it. It helps us cut our teeth as writers and follow through with plot lines and dialogue and how it all works together, without also having to write brand new characters as well.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. omg that’s a huge mood, in terms of word count and time spent reading I’ve definitely gone through as much fanfiction as published novels most years! and sharing it can definitely be daunting, I’m honestly glad that I started posting while I was still too young to have too much shame lol, otherwise I’d probably just have a ton of secret drafts.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Isabelle, I LOVE this post. I’ve been writing fanfiction for…probably 11 years now or something, and I understand every single stage you’ve outlined here, especially the parts about falling away from fic because you’re discouraged or busy with school and offline relationships. But man, fic is really such an important sandbox for readers and writers, and I love to see people talk openly about it!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I think the first fanfic I ever wrote may have been Lord of the Rings or Digimon…haha…but I would say that fanfiction is still a favorite form of writing for me, it’s relaxing and so much fun. I still write it but I mostly stick with video games now. I think it’s a great way to show your appreciation for a love of a certain work!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wait, what do you mean you write Bellarke and I didn’t know about it????????? They’re one of my all-time OTPs.
    But honestly, this post is basically me. I spent almost 3 years only reading fanfiction and I still read a few every month, but not as much as I used to. It still is my go-to when I need a romance fix.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. ahahaha yes I write Bellarke, they’ve been my main OTP for a few years now! (though I don’t think I’ve posted anything new in over a year; every few months I mean to get back into it and then life gets busy πŸ˜…) it’s such a good standby when I feel the desire to drown myself in feels, and it can be so easy to find what you’re looking for whether that’s trope or angst/fluff!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, exactly! I feel like sometimes it’s like coming home because when you pick up a book, usually you don’t know where the plot is going. With fanfiction we can choose exactly what we’ll read, and we can expect where the story is going. And sometimes I miss my favorite characters and reading fanfiction is better than rewatching the shows tbh x:

        Liked by 1 person

  5. I adore this post so much. My relationship with writing fanfiction is a strange one, I tend to write about bands…ahem specifically The Vamps, 5SOS and RoadTrip…I did have a fanfic about The Maze Runner up at one point but bleh. I do thoroughly enjoy rereading my past fanfics though, half finished or finished it’s just a fuzzy feeling. To know that I can write, that people do enjoy my writing.

    Fanfic writing was my escape during my last two years at school, I was in a low point in my life and writing made everything ok. It gave me an escape so instead of revising for GCSE’s I’d be writing…and throughout secondary school even I was working on original stuff. I’d be writing in class…at lunch…but more recently I’ve hit a bit of a wall of a doubt. To the point that I’m struggling working on the WIP I want to because of this doubt. Fanfic though is a great thing.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. yessssss it’s been such a fantastic outlet, and I’m still proud enough of some of my fics to reread them – or sometimes just the comments/reviews for a little self-esteem boost πŸ˜‰ I can definitely relate to feeling kind of “out of the rhythm” of it all though – looking back at my post I was probably overoptimistic since this semester turned out to be such a busy one, but now that i’m on break again fanfic is definitely something I want to fit back into my schedule!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.